Should You Tip on Top of Auto-Gratuity?
A receipt can contain three different lines that all feel like a tip, and only one of them is a tip you still have to decide. A suggested percentage is optional. An automatic gratuity is a charge the restaurant already added, usually for a larger party. A service charge is a fee under the restaurant's own name, and it may or may not be paid out to staff. TipCalc cannot see any of them. If you type the subtotal and then add 20%, the calculator assumes you still owe a tip. This guide is about reading the paper first so you do not pay that tip twice.
Suggested, automatic, and mandatory
A suggested tip is a prompt. It might be printed at the bottom of a paper check as 18%, 20%, and 22%, or it might be three buttons on a card machine. You can choose a different amount, including a smaller one or a larger one. The suggestion is not part of the amount due until you accept it. The mental math guide shows how to test whether those buttons used the pre-tax subtotal or the post-tax total. Matching them is optional.
An automatic gratuity is different. The restaurant has already added a percentage, often around 18% for a party above a size printed on the menu. There is no single national rule for the party size or the percent. Six guests and 18% is a common policy, and plenty of rooms use a different cutoff. Once that line is on the bill, it is part of what you owe under the restaurant's stated policy. It is not a hint sitting next to a blank tip line. Adding TipCalc's 20% on top of it leaves two tips.
A service charge is a fee the business added. It might be labeled service charge, large-party fee, or something similar. It is not the same thing as a tip you chose. Whether the money is paid to servers, pooled, or kept as restaurant revenue depends on the business and on the rules that apply to it. This page cannot settle that for a specific dining room. If the bill does not say where the charge goes, ask. Do not assume it is a tip, and do not assume the staff will never see it.
A receipt that already has 18%
Picture a six-person check. Food and drink subtotal $240.00. Sales tax $19.20, which is 8% in this example only. A printed line says "18% gratuity, party of 6" and the amount is $43.20. That 18% was taken on the pre-tax subtotal: 240 脳 0.18 = 43.20. The amount due before any extra is 240.00 + 19.20 + 43.20 = $302.40, or $50.40 per person if the table is splitting evenly and not adding more.
If someone then opens TipCalc, enters $240 and $19.20, and reads the 20% card, they will see a pre-tax tip of $48.00 and a total due of $307.20. That card is correct for a bill that does not already include a tip. It is the wrong card to pay on top of the $43.20 already charged. Paying both leaves $91.20 of tip-like money on a $240 meal, which is 38% of the subtotal, not 20%. The fix is to notice the gratuity line before you use the percentage cards.
Sometimes you still want to add a small amount because one person was excellent and the automatic charge feels impersonal. Decide the extra as its own number. Five percent of $240 is $12. Type 5 in the custom field, with the same subtotal and tax, and read that tip only. Do not read it and also pay the 20% card. Tell the server or write on the slip that the extra is in addition to the printed gratuity, so it is not mistaken for a replacement. If you do not want to add anything, pay the printed total and leave the tip line alone or write zero, so a blank line is not filled in later as if you forgot.
Other lines that are not a tip
Delivery fees, credit-card surcharges, "kitchen appreciation" fees, healthcare fees, and corkage are not a tip you already left, unless the receipt says in plain language that the fee is the gratuity and that staff receive it. A $5 delivery fee can be the restaurant's charge for sending the order and still leave the driver unpaid by that fee. A 3% card surcharge is the cost of paying by card. A healthcare line is whatever the restaurant says it is. None of those should be typed into TipCalc's tax field. Tax is the sales-tax dollars. Fees are a reason to pause, not an input.
If you still want to tip the person who did the work, compute that tip from the food subtotal, or from a flat amount, after you have understood the fee. For delivery, the how much to tip guide treats the driver as a separate decision from the kitchen, often a percentage with a floor on small orders. Subtract nothing for a fee the driver does not receive. Skip a second tip for a fee the receipt says is already their gratuity.
How to use the calculator without double-counting
Read from the top of the receipt to the bottom once before you type. You are looking for gratuity, service, auto, included, or a party-size note on the menu that matches a line on the bill. If that line is present, the percentage cards are not your next step. Your next step is the amount already due, divided by the people at the table if you are splitting it. You can still use TipCalc for that division by putting the full amount due into the subtotal, leaving tax at zero, leaving the custom percentage empty, and setting Split to the headcount. The per-person line on every card will show the same total, because a 15% tip of a number you do not intend to use is not what you came for. Clearer: do the division yourself, amount due divided by people, and use the calculator only if you are adding a further percentage on purpose.
If the line is absent, then the ordinary path applies. Enter the food subtotal, enter sales tax in the tax field, choose pre-tax or post-tax, and read 15%, 20%, or 25%, or a custom percentage. Turn on round-up only when you want whole-dollar shares. That path is the whole point of the homepage. It assumes the receipt left the tip up to you.
What this site will not decide
TipCalc will not tell you whether a service charge is legal, whether it must be paid to staff, or whether you can force a restaurant to remove it. Those answers depend on the wording on the menu, the receipt, and the rules where you are. The practical table rule is narrower and does not require a legal opinion. If a gratuity is already charged, do not add a full second percentage by reflex. If you add something extra, choose it deliberately and say what it is. If nothing is charged, use the calculator for the tip you actually mean to leave.
The $240 receipt is an example so the double count is easy to see. It is not a standard party policy and it is not tax or employment advice. A restaurant's printed terms control. Questions and corrections go to the site operator at contact@tipcalcs.com.