Should You Tip on Pre-Tax or Post-Tax?
Should the tip be a percentage of the food and drink, or a percentage of the food, the drink, and the sales tax? Etiquette guides usually say pre-tax. The machine on the table often does the opposite, because the post-tax total is the number already on the screen. TipCalc has both, and the difference is small enough to compute exactly instead of arguing about it in the abstract. This page is that computation, and a description of which control does what.
The total you pay always includes three pieces: subtotal, tax, and tip. The tip-basis control does not remove tax from the amount due. It only changes the number the percentage multiplies. Pre-tax multiplies the subtotal. Post-tax multiplies the subtotal plus the tax you entered.
A receipt with the lines separated
Take a dinner check with a $64.00 subtotal and $5.12 of tax. That tax happens to be 8% of 64. The 8% is an example so the arithmetic is visible. It is not a claim about the rate where you are sitting. On TipCalc you would enter 64.00 as the subtotal and 5.12 as the tax.
Pre-tax at 20% uses $64.00. The tip is $12.80. The total due is 64.00 + 5.12 + 12.80 = $81.92. Post-tax at 20% uses 64.00 + 5.12 = $69.12. Twenty percent of 69.12 is $13.824, which rounds to $13.82. The total due is 64.00 + 5.12 + 13.82 = $82.94. Moving from pre-tax to post-tax raised the tip by $1.02 and raised the amount you pay by the same $1.02. The tax dollars themselves did not change.
There is a short formula for that gap, before rounding: subtotal × tax rate × tip rate. Here 64 × 0.08 × 0.20 = 1.024, which is the $1.02 you saw after the tip was rounded to the cent. The same formula is why people say the difference is "about 1% or 2%." An 8% tax and a 20% tip is 1.6% of the subtotal. A 10% tax and an 18% tip is 1.8% of the subtotal. It is not 1% or 2% of the tip. It is that many percent of the food and drink.
A second receipt, so the formula is not a one-off
Subtotal $40.00, tax $4.00, which is 10% in this example. An 18% pre-tax tip is 40 × 0.18 = $7.20. An 18% post-tax tip is 18% of $44.00, which is $7.92. The gap is $0.72. The formula gives 40 × 0.10 × 0.18 = 0.72, with no rounding left over. Type 18 in the custom field, flip the tip basis, and the two tips on the custom card should match those figures if round-up is off and Split is 1.
Round-up will change the tip after the percentage is applied. If you are trying to check the formula, leave round-up off. If you are trying to pay cash in whole dollars, turn it on and expect the tip shown to be a little higher than the strict percentage. The card's percentage label stays the percentage you chose. The dollar tip is the adjusted one. That behavior is described in the splitting guide as well, because round-up is defined per person.
What the fields are for
Subtotal means the food and drink before sales tax. Tax means the dollar amount printed on the receipt, not a percentage you have to guess. If the receipt shows a single total and does not list tax, put that single total in the subtotal and leave tax at 0. Pre-tax and post-tax then multiply the same base, so the toggle does nothing. That is the correct result, not a bug. You do not have a separate tax figure to exclude.
Do not enter the after-tax total as the subtotal and then also enter the tax. On the first receipt, putting 69.12 in the subtotal and 5.12 in the tax field counts the tax twice. A pre-tax 20% tip would be calculated on $69.12, which already contains tax, and the total due would add $5.12 again. You would pay tax twice and tip on tax without meaning to. If you only have the after-tax number, it belongs in the subtotal, alone.
If you know the rate but the receipt already did the multiplication, trust the printed tax dollars. A rate in your head can be wrong about what was taxable. Some items are exempt, a city tax and a state tax may be combined on one line, and a fee might be sitting next to the tax without being tax. The calculator asks for the dollar line so it does not invent a rate.
Why the two habits both persist
Pre-tax treats sales tax as money passing through the restaurant to the government, not as money the server generated. That is the etiquette argument, and it is the default on TipCalc. Post-tax matches what a lot of people actually do, because they tip on "the total" and because suggested buttons are often computed on that total. Neither choice is a statute. If the table already agreed to follow the machine, post-tax keeps everyone on the same base. If you are leaving cash and you want the etiquette version, pre-tax is the one to select.
Card machines and suggested buttons
A terminal that offers 18%, 20%, and 22% is not required to tell you the base. If you want to know, divide the suggested tip by the percentage. A suggested $13.82 on the receipt above, divided by 0.20, is $69.10, which is the post-tax total within a cent of rounding. A suggested $12.80 divided by 0.20 is $64.00, the pre-tax subtotal. You can do that check in your head with the method in the mental math guide, or you can type the receipt into TipCalc, try both bases, and see which tip matches the button.
Matching the button is optional. You can select a custom tip on most machines, or leave cash. If you are comparing, use the same percentage the button claims. An 18% button will not match a 20% card even when the base is identical.
Tax included, and tips that are not percentages
Some menus say tax is included in the price. Then there is no tax line to enter, and the subtotal you were charged is the base. Some bills add a service charge or an automatic gratuity that is not sales tax. Do not type that charge into the tax field. Tax is the sales-tax line. A service charge is a different decision, covered in the service-charge guide: usually you do not add a full second tip on top, and you do not want the calculator to treat the charge as if it were tax the tip should or should not include.
A flat tip, such as $2 on a round of beers, does not have a pre-tax version. The basis toggle matters when you are using a percentage. Leave the percentage cards for the cases they describe.
Figures on this page are worked examples so you can check the calculator. They are not a sales-tax rate for your city and they are not tax advice. Questions about a result can go to the site operator at contact@tipcalcs.com.